Score: 5

"Good music vid"

submission: a tribute to ghostmas

date: October 31, 2008

I really liked how you interpreted the lyrics for the visual elements. Would have liked more work on the visual quality, but I enjoyed it all the same.
Keep creating :)

Score: 5

"I like"

submission: Misfits Halloween

date: October 31, 2008

Animation technique was good. The lip sync was notibly good as well. Work on your drawing a little. Great song choice :)

Score: 6

"I like it!"

submission: Linux VS Windows short

date: October 30, 2008

There's nothing wrong with a short animation. I think your scene planing was good, and your animation technique was fairly smooth.
Taking the length of the animation into account, I would have hoped for a little more work in the detailing of the objects of the animation. I had to watch the animation twice to see that the Linux penguin started off wielding a sword (thought it was a pipe the first time). I think a little work into shading and highlighting would make all the difference :)
Also, remember to cite songs used at the end somewhere (song name + performer). I for one have been trying to get ahold of that track for a long time, and would really appreciate knowing who preformed it so I can find it :)
This could make a great series of short animations. Please make more if you get the chance.

Score: 5

"Suprisingly fun"

submission: Buttons!!!

date: October 30, 2008

Really good, simple concept for a game. In your next version, I think a level indicator somewhere on the display would be awesome. So players can see how many they've completed, or maybe even how many are left to go. Try to avoid images that look pixilated at the intended size of the game window (I noticed a couple were like that).
Also, added choice of music tracks would be a big plus. Volume control, or at least quieter music, would have been nice. I had to turn down my system volume.
Finally, a little more attention to the design and layout of the user interface would be a great improvement as well. Keep it simple, but rethink the colors, and perhaps create a control panel of sorts so it doesn't make the image seem cluttered.
I look forward to another edition of this game.

Score: 2

"Promising style, still needs work"

submission: Massito Banditos: Masks

date: October 30, 2008

I saw promising style in the way you draw you characters. If you put more attention into your backgrounds, and scenery, I'd put at least 3 more stars up. Also had trouble reading the speech text. Consider using speech bubbles, or an alternative? Animation techniqe needs some refinement as well.
Please keep working at it.

Score: 8

"Awesome"

submission: Rockoons 2

date: October 30, 2008

Overall, I liked it. I think the visual style needs just a little more attention. You picked one of my favorite songs from Journey, and I like the visual interpretation you presented. I really liked the scene in the house while it was on fire. Though I think that more could have been done with the flames themselves to make the scene look more lively, and better match the chorus.

Score: 8

"Great action!"

submission: Castle Prologue

date: October 15, 2006

I realy like the action you put in here. I would have liked to see a little more happen in a few of the shots though. The coloring/shading was excelent and music choice was well considered. By the way, what song was used in the trailer?

Score: 9

"Sweet"

submission: lamedontbother

date: February 1, 2006

Overlooking the lack of a loading screen this was awsome. The way you switch between the photo and line varsions of a sceen was just cool. Your coice of music was good and the sync between the sceen and music was well done. You should make a travel seiries using a similer concept :)

Score: 7

"More action plz"

submission: The Zero Dragon ep.2

date: January 21, 2006

There should have been a little more action but it was pretty funny, ya sensitive B@$&^* :P

Score: 6

"Good Laugh"

submission: CC-Element's rant

date: January 21, 2006

Very quick. Thought I was funny how he kept going on about ho no one liked him then points a gun a someone who does. Made me laugh XD